
The County Won in Court. But Who Was Protecting the Public’s Interests?
Sometimes winning a lawsuit raises more questions than losing one.
Santa Cruz County successfully defended itself in Workbench and Sweet Developments LLC v. County of Santa Cruz, et al. (Santa Cruz County Superior Court, Case No. 26CV01095), a lawsuit seeking automatic approval of a proposed 105-unit apartment complex at 3500 Paul Sweet Road.
On October 13, 2026, Superior Court Judge Syda K. Cogliati issued a 14-page order denying Workbench’s petition for writ of mandate. The court concluded that Workbench had effectively agreed to extend the statutory approval deadline by proceeding to a January 14, 2026 Planning Commission hearing without objection. The judge also rejected Workbench’s allegations that County officials had acted in bad faith.
However, a closer examination of the County’s legal defense reveals a critical omission: its attorneys did not directly challenge the underlying Builder’s Remedy eligibility on which Workbench relied to bypass ordinary zoning restrictions.
The County Was Warned
On January 13, 2026, attorney Roy E. Brewer, representing Dominican Hospital and Dominican Oaks, submitted a letter to the County Planning Commission explicitly questioning Workbench’s Builder’s Remedy eligibility. Brewer argued that California’s Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) had effectively found the County’s Housing Element compliant as early as March 15, 2024. If that date were legally controlling, Workbench’s subsequent applications could face a fundamental challenge to their Builder’s Remedy eligibility.
The letter was formally copied to County planning staff and special counsel Natalie Kirkish.
The Board of Supervisors acknowledged the issue’s gravity. On March 10, 2026, the Board voted 4–1 to seek formal recognition of March 15, 2024, as the County’s Housing Element compliance date, sending a formal request to HCD on March 18, 2026. Yet as of October 31, no public record could be found that indicates HCD granted the request; the agency’s formal compliance ledger remains listed as April 12, 2024.
Enter Goldfarb & Lipman LLP
When Workbench sued the County over delayed approvals, Oakland-based firm Goldfarb & Lipman LLP stepped in to represent Santa Cruz County. Their July 6, 2026 opposition brief concentrated strictly on procedural defenses: the Permit Streamlining Act, CEQA determinations, and whether deadline waivers applied. The firm’s attorneys chose not to contest Workbench’s original Builder’s Remedy eligibility based on the March 15 compliance argument.
Their own brief reveals they understood the stakes.
On page 19, Goldfarb & Lipman quoted County Counsel as being “pretty confident” the County would face additional litigation if it attempted to apply an earlier compliance date to the Paul Sweet Road project.
The County evaluated the issue and understood the litigation risks, yet its legal team chose to defend the lawsuit on narrower procedural grounds.
Strategy or Missed Opportunity?
There may have been legitimate tactical reasons for the County’s approach. Fighting HCD’s formal certification date presents a steep legal climb, and a procedural win buys time.
However, when Judge Cogliati issued her October 13 ruling, she went a step further.
In her chronology of events, the judge stated that Workbench had acquired Builder’s Remedy eligibility, a legal premise the court did not independently adjudicate.
The County won its immediate legal battle. But the core question its attorneys left unchallenged now hangs over the judge’s order:
Was Workbench ever entitled to Builder’s Remedy protections in the first place?
To be continued.
More Housing Law & Litigation from The Nub
- California ADU Laws 2027: Can You Build Two Backyard Homes?
- California SB 79, Explained: New Housing Rules Near Transit
- California’s Builder’s Remedy, Explained
- Huntington Beach: The Price of Fighting California Housing Law
- Santa Cruz County Drops the Ball: The Substantial Compliance Fumble
- The Judge’s Dilemma: Builder’s Remedy and Substantial Compliance
- The County Fights Back and Wins Another 60 Days
- The County Fights Back