Santa Cruz County Drops the Ball: The Substantial Compliance Fumble – Workbench and Sweet Developments LLC v. County of Santa Cruz

When Workbench sued Santa Cruz County, its attorneys never argued substantial compliance — the one defense that might have changed everything. The Nub investigates why.

Santa Cruz County drops the ball

No, this isn’t about January 22, 2012, when San Francisco 49ers punt returner Kyle Williams fumbled the football in overtime of the NFC Championship Game.

This is about why Santa Cruz County and its attorneys at Goldfarb & Lipman LLP did not argue substantial compliance in the Paul Sweet Road petition.

On January 13, 2026, attorney Roy E. Brewer sent a letter to the Santa Cruz County Planning Commission alerting officials that the County may have achieved substantial compliance with state Housing Element law as early as March 15, 2024.

Yet when Workbench sued, the County’s attorneys did not argue substantial compliance as a defense to the developer’s underlying eligibility. Why?

April 9, 2024: The Convergence — Two Applications and an Anticipated HCD Compliance Date

Santa Cruz County was anticipating a letter from the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) confirming its Housing Element’s compliance with state law.

On that same date, April 9, 2024, two Workbench development applications reached significant milestones: one for 3500 Paul Sweet Road and the other for 841 Capitola Road.

And remember, Workbench executive Tim Gordin was serving on the Santa Cruz County Planning Commission at the time.

Three events. One remarkably consequential date.

The Brewer Letter

On January 13, 2026, attorney Roy E. Brewer, representing Dominican Hospital and Dominican Oaks, submitted a letter to the Santa Cruz County Planning Commission challenging Workbench’s Builder’s Remedy eligibility at 3500 Paul Sweet Road.

Brewer argued that HCD had effectively completed its substantive review of the County’s Housing Element by March 15, 2024.

The County had been informed of a potential legal challenge to Workbench’s Builder’s Remedy eligibility.

The County’s Own Agenda — March 10, 2026: Seeking an Earlier HCD Compliance Date

Two months after Brewer’s letter, the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors took up the issue.

On March 10, 2026, Agenda Item 25 proposed directing the Board Chair to request that HCD recognize March 15, 2024, as the County’s Housing Element substantial compliance date.

The Board voted 4–1 to proceed, and the County sent its letter to HCD on March 18.

But California law provides another avenue for determining substantial compliance: a court of competent jurisdiction.

Enter the Wolfe

On March 17, 2026, attorney Mark R. Wolfe filed a lawsuit challenging Workbench’s Builder’s Remedy eligibility at 841 Capitola Road, asking the court to determine whether the County had achieved substantial compliance by March 15, 2024.

Six days later, Workbench sued the County over its Paul Sweet Road development, yet the County’s attorneys did not pursue that same substantial compliance argument.

If Wolfe could raise the question in court, why didn’t the County?

The Explanation That Wasn’t

In their July 6 opposition brief, the County’s attorneys explained that the Board’s March 10, 2026 request to HCD was “not … an attempt to strip their Project of its builder’s remedy status,” but rather an effort to continue discussions with HCD at the request of state legislators.

They also quoted County Counsel’s warning that he was “pretty confident” the County would face litigation if it applied an earlier compliance date to Paul Sweet Road.

But by July 6, Workbench had already sued the County.

The question remains: Why didn’t the County’s attorneys argue substantial compliance?

And as for the 49ers…

As of November 4, 2026, the San Francisco 49ers are 6–1, sitting atop the NFC West after opening the season with six consecutive victories. Their only loss came against the Atlanta Falcons, 29–20, on October 25.

They return from their bye week to face the Las Vegas Raiders on November 8.

The 49ers still have plenty of football left to play.

As for Santa Cruz County, it won its lawsuit, but never ran the substantial compliance play.


More Housing Law & Litigation from The Nub

Get to the Nub of the Matter.

Independent journalism and investigations, delivered to your inbox.

One comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *