Santa Cruz Voters Approve Another Tax. But Who Is Watching the Money?

Santa Cruz voters approved another sales tax. Four years after a Civil Grand Jury asked for independent citizens' oversight, the question remains: who is watching the money?

Measure E election results graph

Four years after a Civil Grand Jury recommended independent citizens’ oversight of county sales tax revenues, the Board of Supervisors’ rejection of that recommendation raises new questions following Measure E.

A Promise Made in 2018

Santa Cruz County voters have apparently approved another sales tax increase.

As of 1:53 a.m. Wednesday, November 4, unofficial election returns showed Measure E receiving 59.46% support, comfortably above the simple majority required for passage.

The measure increases the countywide sales tax by half a percentage point for five years, beginning in April 2027. It is projected to generate approximately $27 million annually to help offset federal funding reductions affecting healthcare, food assistance, housing, and other essential services.

But as voters authorize another substantial source of public revenue, an unresolved question from a previous election deserves renewed attention.

Whatever happened to independent citizens’ oversight?

In November 2018, Santa Cruz County voters approved Measure G, another half-cent sales tax increase, applicable to transactions in the unincorporated portions of the county.

The measure’s ballot language explicitly promised that the approximately $5.75 million in annual revenue would be subject to:

Annual audits and independent citizens oversight.

Four years later, the Santa Cruz County Civil Grand Jury investigated whether the county had fulfilled those assurances.

Its June 20, 2022, report, titled Words Matter — Did Measure G Mislead Voters?, concluded that the ballot language had been misleading.

The Grand Jury found that county officials had not adequately explained how independent oversight would function and that staff had not intended to establish additional accountability procedures beyond those already applicable to general government revenues.

The report identified a significant difference between what some voters understood they were approving and what county officials understood themselves to be promising.

The Grand Jury’s Recommendation

The Grand Jury did more than criticize the ballot language.

In Recommendation R7, it called upon the Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors to establish a citizens’ oversight committee by January 1, 2023.

The proposed committee would review detailed financial reports showing how Measure G revenues were collected and spent. The reviews would occur quarterly or semiannually.

The committee would advise the Board of Supervisors, providing an additional level of public scrutiny without taking away the Board’s spending authority.

On August 9, 2022, the Board approved its formal response.

Recommendation R7: WILL NOT BE IMPLEMENTED.

The county explained that Measure G was a general tax, with proceeds deposited into the General Fund, and that the Board of Supervisors already exercised responsibility for spending those funds.

It also maintained that residents could review county budgets, attend public meetings, and communicate with elected officials.

An additional oversight committee, the county argued, would create a “new layer of bureaucracy that is duplicative and unnecessary.”

The county similarly rejected the Grand Jury’s recommendation to provide more detailed financial tracking of Measure G revenues and expenditures.

The disagreement was clear: the Grand Jury called for additional independent scrutiny; the Board maintained that its existing budget and accountability procedures were sufficient.

Enter Measure E

Fast-forward to November 3, 2026.

Santa Cruz County voters have once again expressed support for higher local taxes, this time in response to substantial fiscal pressures affecting essential services.

The need for healthcare, emergency medical services, food assistance, and housing support is real. County officials estimate that federal funding changes will create financial pressures far exceeding the revenue expected from Measure E.

But Measure E is structured as a general tax.

Although its ballot question emphasizes healthcare, food assistance, housing, and essential services, the county’s official impartial analysis expressly states that the revenues can be used for any lawful government purpose.

The Board has adopted spending priorities, but those priorities do not legally restrict how the revenue must be used.

Unlike Measure G’s 2018 ballot question, Measure E makes no promise of independent citizens’ oversight. Its ordinance does not establish a citizens’ oversight committee.

That distinction matters. The county is not repeating the same explicit oversight promise that prompted the earlier Grand Jury investigation.

But the underlying question remains.

If the Board itself determines how the money is spent, and the Board itself oversees those spending decisions, what independent mechanism will allow residents to evaluate whether the new revenue is accomplishing its advertised purposes?

The Question After Election Day

Measure E is projected to collect approximately $135 million over five years if annual revenue meets the county’s estimates.

That is a substantial commitment from Santa Cruz County taxpayers.

The 2022 Civil Grand Jury believed the county’s earlier sales tax measure warranted greater financial transparency and independent oversight. The Board of Supervisors disagreed and rejected its recommendation.

Four years later, voters have authorized another tax increase, and the disagreement remains relevant.

The election may have answered whether voters are willing to pay more.

It has not answered who should be watching how that money is spent.

Primary Sources


Related: Santa Cruz governance

Get to the Nub of the Matter.

Independent journalism and investigations, delivered to your inbox.

5 Comments

  1. Thank you for this good analysis. Indeed, how will there be any accountability at all? It will be up to the public to keep demanding that the Board of Supervisors follow through…I have saved the glossy full=color “Yes on Measure E” mailers to use as a visual.

  2. Falling into the depths of ‘tax and spend’. When will we (the people) ever learn?!? The voter ballot even phrased measure E as a referendum directing tax monies into a general fund!!! I voted ‘No”, and unbelievably the voters were misdirected by the confusing ballot language.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *